Maldon Sea Salt Is a Scam
One of my pet peeves is “artisanal salt” for cooking. That’s one of the most stupid things ever. Salt is NaCl. It comes in different forms, which means the crystals are of a different size, but it’s all NaCl. Sea salt, rock salt, pink salt, black salt, salt from the Himalayas … all of this is NaCl, too. The differences are in the impurities. I’ve never understood buying any salt that isn’t the cheapest, purest table salt. You dissolve it anyway, so why would crystal size matter? And I don’t understand how dirt from the Himalayas or some ocean or some other minute trace elements that change the crystals’ colour would have any taste or health benefits. This is bullshit.
Which is why this story published in The Observer yesterday cracked me up. As it turns out, Maldon Sea Salt Flakes — one of the most popular, and expensive, “artisinal salt” brands — mixes rock salt mined in Germany by the huge industrial conglomerate K+S in with their precious sea salt. They call this a “filtering process” but that’s as stupid as the wholle idea of having “artisanal salt” in the first place. How this shit could become “one of Britain’s most popular artisanal brands” is beyond me.
The tale Maldon Salt tells of its history and craft is hard to resist: for more than 140 years this quintessential British brand has harvested salt on the Essex shoreline, which has been “alive with salt making for almost a thousand years”. Its website features bucolic images of that coastline and black-and-white photographs of artisan salt-makers harvesting the signature white pyramid-shaped crystals, which “release saltiness with sweet precision”.
Thanks to the rise of the celebrity chef and a raft of endorsements, the brand’s star, too, has risen. The salt has been championed by the likes of Delia Smith and Jamie Oliver, among many other leading chefs, and is raved about by a raft of food influencers online. Now a mainstay of middle-class households and the Waitrose food aisle, its global repute has propelled it to annual revenues of about £40m.
Maldon Sea Salt Flakes costs £11.40 / kg at Sainsbury’s right now. Sainsbury’s cheapest table salt costs £1 / kg. But, of course, 75p for a 750 g bottle of salt won’t buy you all that marketing bullshit about releasing saltiness with sweet precision. Seriously, what that fuck? 🤨
But an investigation by The Observer has found there is another side to the Maldon Salt story of “harvesting the water’s salty ebb”. While its label and marketing materials tell consumers the product is “100% sea salt flakes” from Essex, our reporting has established that imported rock salt, mined in Germany, is used in the manufacture of Maldon Salt. The company has been allowed by regulators to use imported rock salt to filter and enrich the seawater. But the imported salt dissolves in the seawater and it has been alleged the practice — known as the “salt-on-salt” method — allows the firm to increase volumes at its main production site near the village of Goldhanger in Essex.
Maldon Salt says its labelling and marketing material describing its product as “100% sea salt flakes” is correct. It considers rock salt was once suspended in prehistoric seas and there is no distinction from sea salt. It is simply ancient sea salt.
So they are basically admitting to what I’m saying: it’s all NaCl! Why are you selling your NaCl at a price almost twelves times that of other NaCl then? Especially if you’re using cheap NaCl from Germany to make your “artisinal” NaCl from Essex?
